What is the Difference Between White and Brown Eggs? – Nutrition, Taste & Myths

You’ve probably stood in front of the egg section at the grocery store and wondered:
What is the difference between white and brown eggs? And more importantly — does it even matter?

Some say brown eggs are healthier. Others think white eggs taste better. The truth? It has less to do with nutrition or flavor… and everything to do with the chickens themselves.

In this article, we’ll crack the egg debate wide open — covering the real difference between white and brown eggs, whether one is better than the other, and what factors actually affect quality.

What is the Difference Between White and Brown Eggs?

The only real difference between white and brown eggs is the color of the shell — and that depends entirely on the breed of the hen that lays it.

• White eggs come from chickens with white feathers and white earlobes, like the White Leghorn.
  
• Brown eggs come from chickens with red or brown feathers and red earlobes, such as Rhode Island Reds or Plymouth Rocks.
  

That’s it — there’s no magic or mystery behind it.

Are They Grown Differently?

Not necessarily. Both types of eggs can be:

• Organic or non-organic
  
• Free-range or cage-raised
  
• Local or store-bought
  

The difference comes down to the hen, not the farming method (though farming practices can influence price and quality).

Why Are Brown Eggs Usually More Expensive?

Brown-egg-laying hens are often larger and eat more, which makes them more expensive to raise. That extra cost gets passed on to you — but it doesn’t mean the egg itself is better.

Are brown eggs healthier than white eggs?

No — brown eggs are not healthier than white eggs.
Despite the common belief, there’s no significant nutritional difference between the two. The shell color doesn’t affect what’s inside.

What Actually Affects Egg Nutrition?

What does make a difference is:

• The hen’s diet
  
• Living conditions (free-range vs. caged)
  
• Farming practices (organic, pasture-raised, etc.)
  

For example, eggs from hens that eat a high-omega-3 diet may contain more omega-3s, and pasture-raised hens may produce eggs with more vitamin D. But this has nothing to do with the color of the eggshell.

Nutrition: Brown vs. White (per large egg, on average)

• Calories: 70
  
• Protein: 6 grams
  
• Fat: 5 grams
  
• Cholesterol: 185 mg
  
• Vitamins & Minerals: Nearly identical
  

Bottom line: If you’re buying eggs based on nutrition, focus on labels like “pasture-raised”, “organic”, or “high omega-3” — not the shell color.

Read:

• How many calories in a teaspoon of butter: Complete nutrition guide.

Does one color of egg taste better?

No — egg color doesn’t affect taste.
White and brown eggs taste the same when raised under similar conditions. The flavor of an egg comes from how the hen is raised, not the color of her shell.

So Why Do Some People Say Brown Eggs Taste Better?

It’s often about perception. Brown eggs are more commonly associated with farm-fresh or organic labels, so people expect them to taste richer. But in blind taste tests, most people can’t tell the difference between white and brown eggs — unless:

• The hen’s diet is different (e.g., flaxseed or herbs)
  
• The eggs are fresher or from a local farm
  
• The cooking method affects texture or flavor intensity
  

What Actually Affects Egg Taste?

• Freshness: Fresher eggs taste better, regardless of shell color
  
• Hen’s diet: Can influence flavor subtly (especially with pasture-raised hens)
  
• Storage time and conditions: Older eggs lose flavor over time
  

Bottom line: If you want great-tasting eggs, look for fresh, well-raised, and locally sourced — not just brown shells.

Why are brown eggs more expensive?

Brown eggs usually cost more — but it’s not because they’re healthier or higher quality.
The real reason? The chickens that lay brown eggs are bigger and eat more.

Here’s What Drives the Price Up:

• Larger hens = more feed
  Brown-egg-laying breeds like Rhode Island Reds require more food than smaller white-egg layers like Leghorns.
  
• Lower production rate
  Some brown-egg-laying hens produce slightly fewer eggs per year, making each egg more expensive to produce.
  
• More common in specialty farms
  Brown eggs are often associated with organic, free-range, or small-farm practices — which also cost more and affect pricing.
  

Does the Higher Price Mean Better Quality?

Not necessarily. Price reflects the cost to raise the hen — not the egg’s nutrition or taste.
If you’re paying more for brown eggs, it may be due to the farm’s practices (e.g., organic or local) rather than the shell color itself.

Bottom line: Brown eggs aren’t “premium” by nature — just more expensive to produce.

If color doesn’t matter, what does?

If you’re shopping for better eggs, don’t judge by the shell — judge by the source. Here’s what really makes a difference in egg quality, nutrition, and taste:

1. Hen’s Diet

What hens eat directly affects the nutrients in their eggs.

• Diets rich in flaxseed can boost omega-3 levels
  
• Natural foraging (bugs, greens) enhances vitamin content
  
• Commercial feed = consistent, but less nutrient-rich
  

2. Living Conditions

Labels like “pasture-raised” and “free-range” usually mean the hen had space to roam, which can affect health and egg quality.

• Pasture-raised: Most natural environment, best egg flavor and nutrients
  
• Free-range: Outdoor access, though limited
  
• Cage-free: Indoor but not in cages
  
• Conventional: Typically confined, low-cost production
  

3. Freshness

The fresher the egg, the better the taste, texture, and structure — especially for baking or poaching.
Tip: Check the packaging date (often printed as a 3-digit Julian date). Lower numbers = fresher eggs.

4. How They’re Stored and Handled

Eggs stored at stable, cool temperatures and not washed in harsh chemicals tend to last longer and retain more nutrients.

5. Certifications and Labels

• Organic: No antibiotics or synthetic feed
  
• Non-GMO: Feed doesn’t contain genetically modified ingredients
  
• Certified Humane: Ensures ethical treatment of hens
  

Bottom line: If you care about taste, nutrition, or animal welfare — look at how the egg was produced, not what color it is.

Why do chefs use brown eggs?

Many people believe chefs prefer brown eggs because they’re fresher, tastier, or more nutritious — but the truth is: chefs don’t care about color — they care about quality.

So why do we often see brown eggs in professional kitchens?

• They’re usually from local farms.
  Many chefs source ingredients from small or organic farms — and those farms often raise brown-egg-laying breeds like Rhode Island Reds or Barred Rocks.
  
• They’re associated with “farm fresh.”
  Brown eggs are often marketed alongside organic, free-range, or pasture-raised practices, which chefs tend to favor for ethical and flavor reasons.
  
• They look more “natural” to consumers.
  In high-end settings, a brown eggshell can visually signal artisanal quality — even if the taste is the same as a white egg.
  

Bottom line:

Chefs aren’t picking eggs by shell color — they’re choosing based on freshness, farming practices, and supplier reputation. It just so happens that many high-quality farms raise hens that lay brown eggs.

Also read:

• Benefits of eating basil leaves daily you didn’t know about.

FAQ

Are brown eggs healthier than white eggs?

No. Brown and white eggs have nearly identical nutrition. The color of the shell doesn’t affect protein, fat, or vitamin content. Nutrition is influenced more by the hen’s diet and environment than the egg’s color.

Why do brown eggs cost more?

Brown-egg-laying hens are often larger and require more feed, which makes them more expensive to raise. That added cost is passed to consumers — but it doesn’t mean the eggs are better.

Do brown eggs taste better than white eggs?

Not inherently. Flavor is shaped by freshness, hen diet, and how the egg is cooked — not by shell color. Many people associate brown eggs with farm-fresh sources, which can taste better, but the color isn’t the reason.

Are white eggs bleached?

No. White eggs are naturally white. Just like brown eggs are naturally brown — it’s all about the breed of the chicken, not any treatment or bleaching.

Which color egg is better for baking?

Either works just as well. If the egg is fresh and properly stored, white and brown eggs perform the same in baking, cooking, and poaching.

Do chefs prefer brown eggs?

Chefs usually care more about freshness and sourcing than shell color. Brown eggs are more common at local farms or specialty producers, which is why they may appear more often in restaurant kitchens.

Conclusion

When it comes to the difference between white and brown eggs, the answer is simpler than most people think:
The color of the shell comes from the hen — not the quality of the egg.

There’s no meaningful nutritional or taste difference between white and brown eggs on their own. What does matter is how the hens are raised, what they’re fed, and how fresh the eggs are by the time they reach your kitchen.

So next time you’re standing in front of the egg aisle, remember:
Don’t judge an egg by its shell — judge it by its source.